livejournal, fanfiction.net and ao3
which one were you?
More you might like
the three generations of fanfic:
I HAVE LITERALLY LIVED THROUGH ALL OF THEM WHAT THE FUCK DOES THAT SAY ABOUT ME
Oh bb there is so much more to it than that.
First there were zines, lovingly mimeographed and stapled by our fandom foreparents, and those who remain to us from the Zine Age are powerful and wise.
Then there was Usenet, where formatting went to die. You know not the strength it takes to read 60k fics entirely in Courier New, or the pleasure of a really artistic looking section break marker composed of ASCII characters.
Then there was the Great Schism, as fandoms spread far and wide across the Web, and basic HTML was the whole of the law. Many of us lied our way into private “18+” listservs, and roamed the webrings, lamps aloft, in search of one virtuous author (or at least somebody else who shipped the thing).
From this dark age rose FF.net, that pit of voles from whose bourn many a hungry reader has returned, starved for citrus and heartsick from the cutesy author notes.
And FF.net begat Livejournal, which allowed easy archiving, threaded comments, flocked posts and invite-only communities. And it was Livejournal, in its death throes, that begat AO3, which once seemed like only a utopian vision and now bestrides the world like a Colossus.
OH MY GOD, REMEMBER WEBRINGS?
Hey. This is the beginning of the DVD where it says the opinions expressed in the commentary (submission) do not reflect those of the distributer (Space Mom).
I cannot stress enough how little of a reylo shipper or a keylo stan I am, but for G-d’s sake some of you people need to learn how to consume media critically. Like, actually critically, not “if this character was real and did the things they did in real life he would be an irredeemable bastard and so he shouldn’t get a redemption arc.” What the fuck, guys? Yes, the motherfucker tortured people and killed his dad and was complicit in literal genocide, but that’s just bad writing. We’re meant to consider him a villain in the same way we considered Vader a villain, but one of the ways they tried to convince us was destroying planets. But no one in the entire series ever actually ACTS like a planet has been destroyed, least of all Leia, who in IV seems super cool about the whole thing immediately. It’s a characterizing flourish that is as clumsy and as miscalculated as it is common to the series. If you read this and think I’m saying anything close to “genocide and depictions of genocide are okay,” that’s exactly the problem I’m talking about. The sequel trilogy mirrored (and magnified) the original trilogy not just because they learned after the prequels that audiences wanted less new stuff, but because the sequels leaned heavily on the idea of inheritance. Kylo Ren tortured Rey and blew up planets because Vader tortured Leia and blew up planet(s?). What we want for villains in fiction should not necessarily be what we want for villains in reality and the fact that this distinction is so rarely made is deeply troubling to me. If Avatar: The Last Airbender wasn’t a show for kids (or, at least, on a network for kids), Zuko probably would’ve killed people and you guys would say he shouldn’t have a redemption arc. Let me be clear: the bad writing is not that a villain gets redeemed, but that a villain meant for redemption is characterized poorly. Make the distinction, please, I’m begging you. All the discourse typed about characters not meeting the standards of perfect moral rectitude necessary to be liked creates genuine moral failure when people who like the story are forced to defend evil actions as if they were committed in reality. It would be, without hyperbole, exhausting to bridge over from the previous point to this next and perfectly expand on it, so let me just briefly say: in the same way that characterization descends into caricature because broad narrative strokes are often necessary to illustrate fine points (he’s a villain, so he must act cruelly even if he is to be redeemed, so let’s have him DESTROY PLANETS), it is often necessary for writers of fiction to use tropes to convey something fresh. The redemption arc of a mildly sympathetic villain is a trope, a narrative caricature, used as a vehicle for the author’s unique story. To simply say that villain redemption is old and overdone is to fundamentally misunderstand how fiction is created and structured.
Submission: I re-learned some new things
aesthetic
story by @bakingstreetsarah aka StarMaple on Ao3
>>read/bookmark on Ao3<<
Please do not repost :)
Anonymous asked:
ao3commentoftheday answered:
Because AO3 is a hosting service. They don’t exist to police the content on their site as long as that content doesn’t breach the Terms of Service.
It’s an author’s responsibility to tag and rate and warn their fics appropriately. It’s a reader’s responsibility to read those tags and ratings and warnings and decide whether or not they want to read the fic. Anyone who isn’t willing to do their part probably shouldn’t be using the service.
If you walk into a haunted house, they are going to try to scare you.
If you get on a roller coaster, you are going to experience g-forces.
If you watch an R-Rated movie, you are going to experience foul language, violence, and/or sexual situations.
If you use a website that caters to all writers of fan-fiction, you are going to encounter every possible thing that comes under that umbrella.
Before you do something that might make you uncomfortable, stop and think.
You have the right and the responsibility to curate your own experiences in these spaces.
I’m an AO3 user (reader & writer), and for a long time all I did was hit the appropriate warnings they had already set up (i.e. Major Character Death), as I had been a long-time user of Fanfiction.net, and was more accustomed to their layout/rules/methods. Then, I started noticing that AO3 authors didn’t just have notes saying, “The following is a work of fanfiction and I do not own the characters Luke Skywalker, Spock, James Bond, etc.”, but had these, “This Fic Contains”, and, “Trigger Warnings/Possible Triggers”.
After reading that, I went to DoesTheDogDie.com and saw where they had expanded what had formerly just been letting you know if the animals in movies/shows died, to having all these ‘trigger warnings’ like if people are shown being violently ill on screen, does the torture scene include damage to the eyes, is someone sexually assaulted on screen, does a child die on screen, etc. After reading many of those, I realized how many things you might want to be aware of and I started trying to be more mindful when I published fanfictions, to say that at the top, “Trigger Warning- mentions of drowning, nightmares related to traumatic events”, and the like to let people know what they are in for. Most of the time, it isn’t something that will ‘spoil’ the story, it is just something to stop people from reading my story if my story is going to upset them.
I don’t write to hurt people, I don’t write to make someone have nightmares. Think of it as something like a Drug Facts/Warning label, and people read it and then either decline the medication or sign the consent form to get the medication. You write up this little thing saying, “The Following Fic Contains x, y, and z”, the reader scans that and goes, “Okay, I can deal with all that- lets get to reading!”, or they go, “Yeah, I can’t deal with Y cause it reminds me of bad things, so I’ll go check something else out. Maybe this author has something else I’d like that doesn’t have Y in it.”
But AO3 allows creators to create and consumers to consume- and all freely, at your own discretion. If a reader wants to read about tentacles doing unspeakable things to stranded explorers, there’s likely a fic (or 1,000) for them on AO3. If a reader wants to read some tooth-rottingly sweet fairy-tale rewrite of Steve Rogers & Natasha Romanov’s lovestory, there’s a fic (or a few) for them on AO3. If you’ve got this fanfic you wrote that is Justice League- but with Zombies, there’s a tag waiting for you, so you can post that to AO3. If you want to publish this little fanfiction you wrote 4 years ago, for a dead fandom that probably had 100 members to begin with, there’s a slot for that on AO3.
This is one place where as a reader and as a writer, you have the freedom to choose what you want and not have to worry about 50-11 people butting in on you to tell you how to change what you want in order to use their service. On A03, you can pretty much read what you like (Cause someone will have posted it, surely) and you can write what you please.
Doesthedogdie.com is a good resource on getting the hang of what you might want to use content warnings for!

Hey so if any of y’all are or have been volunteers for Ao3, PLEASE be careful when checking your emails
And if you know somebody who’s a volunteer I’d check in with them and see if they’re aware of this
to be 100% clear: OTW volunteers are getting CSAM in their emails. as a protest against AO3’s content. I repeat: someone is sending actual literal child pornography to actual literal human people in order to protest fanfic they think is inappropriate.









